Yeah, nice idea.
Or with the recent information about aberrant break events increasing in frequency, it could be that the first time someone or something became aberrant, it created a rut that other things could slide along. And loads of magic that had previously been safe, slipped and caused break events, somehow causing what they call the cataclysm.
I think I remember someone proposed titans could have been aberrants. So maybe a load of break events happened, with people becoming aberrants (including titans) and civilisation collapsed.
But also, it’s said the titans were killed, whereas some aberrants can’t be contained by sundered zones, and aberrants don’t have a standard stature and don’t typically go around eating things. Maybe titans already existed, but some of their magic had mini break events and they went mad and propagated the effects or something.
Or, um, what else, if magic broke then maybe this affected the elemental planes too, with whatever consequences.
Maybe the Red Guard want thaumaturge education to be strictly limited, so that people will be taught to be careful with magic and not to become aberrants, so Oliver’s idea won’t be permitted.
I’ve not studied Buddhist or Hindu thought much at all, but I’ve heard of the idea of karma. In the Buddhist idea of karma, unlike the Hindu one, it’s not about a soul being affected by its karma from a previous life. Instead, your decisions/actions/something create karmic seeds, and that karmic seed can then affect a future person, so you might feel responsibility to make good decisions so that future people will be affected by your good rather than bad karmic seeds.
And some (Hindu or Buddhist?) thinkers generalised karma to the entire cosmos, not just our minds. And then we can get into the experimental evidence for this, like the measured melting points of chemicals that have only recently been crystallised gradually increasing, whereas chemicals that have long crystallised in nature have their measured melting points steady. For example, some amino acids fit one category, some fit the other.
And people can become unable to get a certain crystal form of a chemical after another (more stable?) one has formed somewhere.
One (unfortunately untested) hypothesis to explain this is seed crystals being carried on the air around the world. Maybe some religious people might say it seems like karma. In PGTS people might think it’s magic. In [other fictional setting] people might think it’s [lore in that fictional setting].
What else ummmm
Oh, captain Eliezer is introduced in chapter 26.
(looking at my electronic notes, not finding another one in them)