Shadow Actions (201-203 spoilers)

This is a sort of placeholder starting post for theories and discussion of the information about and the actions of Siobhan’s shadow/abherrant/dissociative-personality thing.

I know the next chapter is getting released in a few hours but I won’t get to read it for the next 18+ hours so I’m starting by putting down the two discussion subjects that jumped to my mind while reading Ch 201:

  1. What was the shadow-thing doing while Siobhan was running away? It seems to me that it made a new bet with the agents and won somehow.

  2. Siobhan still has the ability to split her will without the help of the shadow thing. How? Is she really just not fully human?

Also, I’m looking forwards to perhaps seeing:

  • Prof Lacer reacting to what the Red Guard agents did given his current friendly relationship with the RQ.
  • The shadow-thing becoming S’s radar and secondary magic assistant.
  • S trying to make the shadow-thing sleep for her instead of having to use ravens.
  • S trying to grow/make something from the abherrant Newton hair sample.
  • Extra strange behavior of Sebastian that is caused by shadow-thing-related-paranoia which gets misinterpreted by everyone around her.

Feel free to add your theories/questions/comments/etc. We could get lucky and have Azalea answer a question or two over the hiatus :smiley:

Thoughts on Siobhan’s shadow or ‘sealed memory’ - could it be a reflection of her childhood encounter with an aberrant (her mother)???

1 Like

The interesting question now is what exactly is trapped in her head.

I think it’s likely that Siobhan thinks it’s an Abberant. Of course she previously demonstrated an obsessive level of Aberrant knowledge in class — but especially, there’s this quote from 202:

Depending on what they decided her shadow was—though the most obvious conclusion seemed hard to deny—they would only be even more intent on her destruction.
Or whatever it was they really did to Aberrants.

So the question is — who became the Aberrant?

It could be a stranger. The interesting options are that it’s Siobhan herself — a piece of her Will broken off and corrupted — or it’s her mother, kept secure by Raaz after transforming, in a room with a lead door.

Some quotes about The Incident:

Her bare feet passed over the sticky, red, fungus-like tendrils that had crept their way over the stone floor. […] The mirror, a rectangle taller than it was wide, was framed in smoldering brimstone, carved in the shape of twisted and elongated limbs […] Her eyes dragged themselves up to the reflection, which showed not her, but a window looking out over a surreal landscape that had been painted in muted earth tones and fog. In the distance, hunched forms shuffled. As she stared, they became more defined. […] Finally, the smoldering brimstone face at the top of the mirror came into view, bound into the frame. Siobhan tried not to recognize it.

Those glowing amber eyes were familiar, and for a moment, a flash of blood and brain matter pooling out in front of the fire came to mind.

That was followed by a blink-fast vision of an egg with a yolk made of blood.

And then, even faster and on the edge of passing too quickly for her mind to grasp, a doorway filled with hungry sky.

there are a few ways one might describe me. For the moment…I suppose you can consider me a sealed, but not quite forgotten, memory

This wasn’t nearly as bad as the sensory scramble and deep, horrifying wrongness had been when Newton broke, though

A way to somehow strip a being from their body and condense their consciousness into information, then encode it into the form of a memory? Memories are never forgotten, but by breaking all connective bonds of recollection, one could force forgetfulness and thus lock the memory, and the consciousness, away.

Because Grandfather had missed one of her memories, the one he didn’t know she had.

Grandfather had died to save her.

And then the Red Guard had come in and razed the entire village to the ground. They had to, to destroy the infection.

I heard there’s a town near Vale that had a bad Blight-type twenty years ago. The whole town is still trapped inside a sundered zone.”

The words produced a small flutter of actual, physical anxiety in Siobhan’s chest.

[Miakoda] died when Siobhan was young, you said?

She didn’t care about me or little Siobhan anymore, only the magic. I didn’t see ‘er when she died. Kal said it was a mercy. I wouldna’ recognize ‘er corpse…

[He insinuated] you had contact with a Blight-type Aberrant as a child […] When you were a baby, the town near Vale that got encapsulated in a sundered zone. Spalding, I think he said?

The mirror is made of brimstone, and Miakoda was a demon witch who cast magic through her flesh, and whose body Raaz wouldn’t let Ennis see, right around the time there was a Blight-type Aberrant near Vale.

When Siobhan was thirteen the Red Guard had to raze their town, so whatever Aberrant was there didn’t end with her mental sealing. That implies she was just one of many victims, which implies Blight-type too (as do the “tendrils”).

My guess is that Miakoda turned into an Aberrant — the mirror — but Raaz took it and Siobhan to safety and kept it for himself (either under the noses of the Red Guard, or by stealing it afterward). At age thirteen Siobhan snuck into its sealed room, got infected, and started to spread the effect again. The mirror Aberrant propagated by creating a malevolent split personality of the person themself. Siobhan went to Raaz for help, and he sealed away her evil copy — somehow dying in the process. My guess there would be that he killed himself to stop his infection-copy from killing Siobhan. After all, he died sitting in a chair, his head having exploded.

Regarding her splitting her Will, she didn’t actually split it into two effects plus the shadow, did she? I think whatever happened to allow her to split her Will is inherent, due to the Aberrant effect she experienced, and not something actively aided by the sealed memory itself.

Though it’s also possible it’s her bloodline.

Perhaps the Naughts had managed to slip through the cracks, the secrecy of the People keeping them out of modern records, maintaining their abilities through careful breeding, or even inbreeding.

Or, perhaps the Blood Emperor’s experiments had not been so fruitless, after all.

This changed everything.

Raaz Kalvidasan, Siobhan Naught’s adopted grandfather, may have had some connection to the Third Empire’s cohort.

I cannot think of any living mortal species that can truly multitask. It is said that the brillig could, but they didn’t interbreed with humans, and they are all long gone, now. Myrddin was almost certainly a full-blooded human.

It’s possible that Siobhan is part-Brillig, part-Null. Innate affinity to magic, combined with an innate resistance to it? Sounds like something a Third Empire survivor would be interested in. With all the theorizing about The People and the Naught side, I wonder what’s in Ennis’ bloodline? We know he’s truly her father-by-blood. Then again, I think the mirror-Aberrant-encounter is a more likely cause for a Will-splitting ability.

2 Likes

The possibility of the aberrant being a remnant of Siobhan’s mother is so interesting!

I’m still waiting for the full RQ-Lacer discussion…

1 Like

Totally. Looking forward to the hijinx that follow from their many mutual misunderstandings, but also I really want to know what Thaddeus is up to. He’s an expert in the pre-Cataclysm world, and he’s very interested in sapient Aberrants. But also…

If she were looking at the text before him—records of those who had lost themselves to magic thousands of years ago—would she be able to read them? Would she understand the significance of his research?

She was too volatile, too inclined to risky undertakings to be a viable partner. And his work was too important to gamble.
Perhaps, though, that would make her the perfect test subject.

I think the thing in Siobhan’s head is older. It might very well be an effect promulgated by an aberrant from Myrddin’s time that makes split will casting possible. Exposing then sealing it could be a long tradition passed down from one Sorcerer to another. But, it could be that Myrddin did find the plane of darkness, and let something out, which Siobhan has in her head - which would explain its intelligence.

In fact, I feel like the mirror was likely her grandfather’s aberrant, but why he cast a spell that went that far, I can’t decide. He may have been trying to pass his consciousness into her (a theory which makes him either the Blood Emperor or Myrddin or both).

But it may also be the gateway to the place Myrddin’s mirror monster comes from, or as you say, not the Aberrant the destroyed the village.

1 Like

My opinion on this has changed a lot, and likely will continue to change, but here is my current read on things:

  • The mirror rimmed with brimstone and not showing a reflection clearly seems to be a planar portal, likely leading to the plane of darkness.

  • There were clearly aberrant shenanigans ongoing when this portal was open. Either a confined aberrant escaped coincidentally while the portal was open, or some collaborator had a break event while opening the portal.

  • She had a memory of something her grandfather didn’t know about, presumably from the time she was sneaking around peaking through doors, a memory he knew about and sealed off which became in some way connected fo that memory, and then, later, the traumatic memory of finding his corpse which she associates with those

Here’s how I currently piece those bits together, and my sequence of events, with a few unconfirmed leaps:

Contact with the plane of darkness and anything from it is inherently corrupting just as energy from the plane of radiance is inherently purifying. This is where the concept of will corruption came from, where energy from the plane can corrupt one’s will in some way.

Since the Brillig essentially had 2 wills and could compartmentalize their minds so that this wasn’t as great of a risk to them as it was to other sapient species, they were one of the few who could semi-safely do research upon the plane of darkness, and I’m going to guess that the danger this presented is what made humans go all genocidal towards them.

In response, the Brillig intentionally contaminated The Black Wastes with energy from the plane of darkness, both to try to protect their small remaining population and to get back at humanity, making for a self-fulfilling prophecy. The Black Wastes are thus the majority of how we can get glances at the effects of the plane of darkness, inevitable madness with increasing exposure.

With that as background, we have Miakoda, Siobhan’s mother, casting through her flesh and struggling to survive it. Raaz Kalvidasan, in my reading, regardless of any initial intentions that were probably bad, has grown to genuinely care for Mia as a daughter, so will do anything to save her, and thus comes up with a plan.

He is aware of the plane of darkness and how to access it (but obviously has never visited) and figures out that with the right material from the plane of darkness and the right spell, he will be able to remove Mia’s ability to cast entirely, and thus prevent her will strain from ultimately killing her, giving her a possible chance to recover. This is an act of self-sacrifice, as he knows his sanity is essentially forfeit in this process.

He goes to the plane of darkness, but while he’s on the other side of the portal Siobhan sneaks away, spies on him, and catches a glimpse of it through his door.

While he is gone, however, either Mia or someone Raaz has called in to help him with this process suffers a break event and becomes a blight type. I’m guessing the spell that provokes it was some sort of healing spell intended to help her. The blight spreads and probably infects Mia if it didn’t start with her, making Raaz’s gesture useless.

Raaz returns and finds his adoptive daughter already gone. When he returns Siobhan sees something he has brought back with him to try to help, and he uses it in a different way than intended to keep the aberrant from reaching Siobhan. In utter desperation he then blocks her memories so the corruption can’t spread via her remembering the plane, and frantically works to finish the protective amulet for her before his mind goes completely.

But because he didn’t know of her brief glimpse of the portal, he didn’t block that memory.

So basically I’m guessing that her passenger is a maddened version of Siobhan that has been forced to watch her own body acting without her.

4 Likes